State of Suffering: Curbing the Rise of Utah Suicides
November 4, 2022
Utah's suicide rate (per 100,000) is nearly double the national rate. That’s a sobering statistic. What’s worse, suicide is the leading cause of death among one of Utah’s youngest groups: teens aged 15-19. In the face of climbing Utah suicides, can we save a suffering state? Can we afford not to?
As a child, loneliness dogged Julia Ludlow like an unwanted shadow. After years of struggling to make friends, she had resigned herself to a life of solitude: quiet rides home on the school bus and nights cooped up in her bedroom, hermit-like, with no one to talk to.
Despite book smarts and a gentle demeanor, Julia struggled to connect. She felt invisible, suffocating under the isolation, until one fall day like any other in 2015, when she packed a dusty Altoid mint tin with as many Tylenol pills as she could fit. Later that afternoon, she would retreat into a quiet alcove near her school cafeteria in northern Utah and attempt to end her life. She was 13.
Luckily, fate intervened. While collecting water to wash down the rest of her pills, Julia ran into a classmate and shared her secret in between sobs. Something broke inside of her, and she agreed to meet with the school counselor and complete a mental evaluation form. “When I checked the box that said I wanted to kill myself, the fear on my parents’ faces was something I’ve never seen before,” she says.
While Julia felt utterly alone, there are many more like her. An unrelenting stigma and limited access to mental health care has been linked to a disturbing rise in suicides across the state, with some victims as young as nine.
There’s Lilith Shlosman, who first attempted suicide as a freshman due to bullying and other factors. In January 2013, 12-year-old Dylan Aranda died of suicide. By December, 30 other teens would do the same.
In 2017, Herriman High School student Chandler Voutaz died by suicide using a firearm. (Firearms are involved in about half of all teen suicide deaths.) Less than a year later, six more students from Chandler’s school had joined him.
As a child, loneliness dogged Julia Ludlow like an unwanted shadow. After years of struggling to make friends, she had resigned herself to a life of solitude: quiet rides home on the school bus and nights cooped up in her bedroom, hermit-like, with no one to talk to.
Despite book smarts and a gentle demeanor, Julia struggled to connect. She felt invisible, suffocating under the isolation, until one fall day like any other in 2015, when she packed a dusty Altoid mint tin with as many Tylenol pills as she could fit. Later that afternoon, she would retreat into a quiet alcove near her school cafeteria in northern Utah and attempt to end her life. She was 13.
Luckily, fate intervened. While collecting water to wash down the rest of her pills, Julia ran into a classmate and shared her secret in between sobs. Something broke inside of her, and she agreed to meet with the school counselor and complete a mental evaluation form. “When I checked the box that said I wanted to kill myself, the fear on my parents’ faces was something I’ve never seen before,” she says.
While Julia felt utterly alone, there are many more like her. An unrelenting stigma and limited access to mental health care has been linked to a disturbing rise in suicides across the state, with some victims as young as nine.
There’s Lilith Shlosman, who first attempted suicide as a freshman due to bullying and other factors. In January 2013, 12-year-old Dylan Aranda died of suicide. By December, 30 other teens would do the same.
In 2017, Herriman High School student Chandler Voutaz died by suicide using a firearm. (Firearms are involved in about half of all teen suicide deaths.) Less than a year later, six more students from Chandler’s school had joined him.
More Utah teens die from suicide than the four other leading causes of death—poisoning, car accidents, homicide, and other injuries—combined. Because of this, Utah and a stretch of surrounding states in the Mountain West have been aptly named the “suicide belt.”
The "suicide belt" refers to a collection of states in the Mountain West with elevated suicide rates. (As you move your cursor across the map, you'll see individual suicide rates.)
While youth suicides have slowly risen across the nation, Utah’s rate has soared. In 2015, the nation’s average teen suicide rate stood at 4.2 per 100,000. That same year, Utah’s stood at a horrifying 11.1. In the last two decades alone, the state’s youth suicide rate has tripled.
*Sources to all data points and statistics referenced within this story can be found here.
More Utah teens die from suicide than the four other leading causes of death—poisoning, car accidents, homicide, and other injuries—combined. Because of this, Utah and a stretch of surrounding states in the Mountain West have been aptly named the “suicide belt.”
While youth suicides have slowly risen across the nation, Utah’s rate has soared. In 2015, the nation’s average teen suicide rate stood at 4.2 per 100,000. That same year, Utah’s stood at a horrifying 11.1. In the last two decades alone, the state’s youth suicide rate has tripled.
*Sources to all data points and statistics referenced within this story can be found here.
UTAH TEEN SUICIDES PER YEAR
In 1999, 12 Utah teens committed suicide. By 2019, that number more than tripled to 42. A consistent upward spike, alongside some small dips, throughout this time period are marked along this line. (Label: year = number of suicides.)
When Julia attempted suicide in 2015, she was one of more than 4,500 Utahns who tried to take their lives—one of the highest years on record. This line graph of Utah teen suicides, and that of the overall Utah suicide rate below, experienced similar spikes in 2015.
UTAH YOUTH SUICIDES
Suicide is the
#1
cause of death
for Utahns aged 10-17
Utah children
as young as
9
years old
have expressed thoughts of
depression and suicide
Utah’s youth suicide
rate has more than
tripled
in the last two decades alone
IT'S NOT ONLY TEENS, THOUGH
Utah’s overall suicide rate has soared above the national average for more than 20 years.
In fact, Utah has the 6th highest suicide rate in the nation.
UTAH YOUTH SUICIDES
Suicide is the
#1 cause of death
for Utahns aged 10-17
Utah children
as young as 9 years old
have expressed thoughts of
depression and suicide
Utah’s youth suicide
rate has more than
tripled
in the last two decades alone
UTAH SUICIDES
It’s not only teens, though.
Utah’s overall suicide
rate has soared above
the national average
for more than 20 years
In fact, Utah has the
6th highest suicide rate
in the nation.
Suicide isn’t often a decision made in a single moment. It can be a choice to end life after a string of painful experiences: job stress, a breakup, the inability to connect with others. No one is immune to these struggles.
Julia Ludlow was one of the lucky ones—with her parents’ help, she soon saw a mental health counselor. But for every 100,000 Utah children in need of mental health care, there are only six child psychiatrists. Between physician shortages and spotty health insurance coverage, struggling teens are often forced to wait several weeks for a simple consultation—weeks beset by the very issues they sought help for in the first place.
Children like Julia deserve better. So how do we do that? To help a suffering, tech-dependent generation, can we meet them where they are? The answer lies in the SafeUT app.
Free. Confidential. Available 24/7. Launched in 2016 by a statewide commission, SafeUT taps into the tech divide by offering around-the-clock crisis intervention. Users can avoid lengthy waitlists, psychiatric provider shortages, and costly deductibles to find help right when and where they need it.
That often means late at night, as the app’s busiest times are between 7 pm and midnight. During this time, students are out of school, have eaten dinner with their family, and are alone in their rooms where they feel safest. Here, problems pushed down during the day resurface: bullying, anxiety, substance abuse, and general stress. Usually, confiding in friends offers no solution; talking to parents brings no comfort.
Licensed therapists from the University Neuropsychiatric Institute (UNI) are humbled to take each call. They recognize just how vulnerable a young life surrounded by screens can be. “It used to be you’d go to school and be bullied during the day,” says Ross Van Vranken, executive director of UNI. “Now it’s 24/7 if somebody wants to do that.”
When it comes to threats of suicide, UNI therapists are tasked with gleaning enough information in time to perform an “active rescue” if needed. These rescues are not uncommon, and the anonymity of the app—while a source of comfort for users—often means therapists will not know the fate of those reaching out.
Shouldering that burden isn’t always easy, as most SafeUT therapists will admit. One counselor, though, calls it “an honor to sit with someone in that darkest of spaces.” The work, however difficult, is certainly worthwhile. After all, the prize is life.
*As of August 2019, UNI will be incorporated into the Huntsman Mental Health Institute with an expected launch in January 2021.
Suicide isn’t often a decision made in a single moment. It can be a choice to end life after a string of painful experiences: job stress, a breakup, the inability to connect with others. No one is immune to these struggles.
Julia Ludlow was one of the lucky ones—with her parents’ help, she soon saw a mental health counselor. But for every 100,000 Utah children in need of mental health care, there are only six child psychiatrists. Between physician shortages and spotty health insurance coverage, struggling teens are often forced to wait several weeks for a simple consultation—weeks beset by the very issues they sought help for in the first place.
Children like Julia deserve better. So how do we do that? To help a suffering, tech-dependent generation, can we meet them where they are? The answer lies in the SafeUT app.
Free. Confidential. Available 24/7. Launched in 2016 by a statewide commission, SafeUT taps into the tech divide by offering around-the-clock crisis intervention. Users can avoid lengthy waitlists, psychiatric provider shortages, and costly deductibles to find help right when and where they need it.
That often means late at night, as the app’s busiest times are between 7 pm and midnight. During this time, students are out of school, have eaten dinner with their family, and are alone in their rooms where they feel safest. Here, problems pushed down during the day resurface: bullying, anxiety, substance abuse, and general stress. Usually, confiding in friends offers no solution; talking to parents brings no comfort.
Licensed therapists from the University Neuropsychiatric Institute (UNI) are humbled to take each call. They recognize just how vulnerable a young life surrounded by screens can be. “It used to be you’d go to school and be bullied during the day,” says Ross Van Vranken, executive director of UNI. “Now it’s 24/7 if somebody wants to do that.”
When it comes to threats of suicide, UNI therapists are tasked with gleaning enough information in time to perform an “active rescue” if needed. These rescues are not uncommon, and the anonymity of the app—while a source of comfort for users—often means therapists will not know the fate of those reaching out.
Shouldering that burden isn’t always easy, as most SafeUT therapists will admit. One counselor, though, calls it “an honor to sit with someone in that darkest of spaces.” The work, however difficult, is certainly worthwhile. After all, the prize is life.
*As of August 2019, UNI will be incorporated into the Huntsman Mental Health Institute with an expected launch in January 2021.
THE PROBLEM
Utah ranks
6th
in the nation
for highest number
of suicides
There are
only 6
child psychiatrists
for every 100,000
children in Utah.
The national average
is approximately
twice that
THE SOLUTION
To help bridge this gap,
SafeUT provides mental
health counseling
to more than
734K
students across
the state
In the four years since its creation, the number of tips and chats submitted through the app has soared by more than 600 percent. That surge is one of many reasons why nearly 1,000 schools have enrolled in the SafeUT app, at all levels of education.
For Lori Thorn, director of student services at Alpine School District, enrolling 76 of her schools in SafeUT has given students a safe space at their fingertips and identified at-risk youth who may otherwise fall under the radar.
"The more students use this, the more the perception of getting help has changed," she says. "That's exciting, because it's a huge battle to reach out for help."
SafeUT use by county: the larger the circle, the more schools enrolled. (As you hover over each county, you'll see the number of schools.)
SafeUT has further expansions in the works, including one for the Utah National Guard that extends mental health support to more than 7,000 service members and their families. In its first six months alone, the SafeUT National Guard app was downloaded by 1,000 members. And this year, SafeUT received the 2020 Best of State Award for Best Web-based Community Resource.
In the four years since its creation, the number of tips and chats submitted through the app has soared by more than 600 percent. That surge is one of many reasons why nearly 1,000 schools have enrolled in the SafeUT app, at all levels of education.
For Lori Thorn, director of student services at Alpine School District, enrolling 76 of her schools in SafeUT has given students a safe space at their fingertips and identified at-risk youth who may otherwise fall under the radar.
"The more students use this, the more the perception of getting help has changed," she says. "That's exciting, because it's a huge battle to reach out for help."
SafeUT has further expansions in the works, including one for the Utah National Guard that extends mental health support to more than 7,000 service members and their families. In its first six months alone, the SafeUT National Guard app was downloaded by 1,000 members. And this year, SafeUT received the 2020 Best of State Award for Best Web-based Community Resource.
The moments preceding suicide are an opportunity to understand those populations vulnerable to suicide. Scott A. Langenecker, PhD (background, at right) is one of several U of U researchers committed to studying the link between mental illness, suicide, and the brain.
And when we understand those vulnerable to suicide, we can better support them before it’s too late. Douglas D. Gray, MD, professor of psychiatry at the University of Utah, has been doing just that.
He first started studying the social and cultural factors behind Utah’s rising youth suicides in the late 1990s. At the time, Gray was one of only two people studying suicide in the state. “To help educate people, I used to fill my old Honda Civic with training pamphlets and hand them out on the weekends,” he says. “It was the loneliest job in town.”
Now, 20 years later, Gray is astounded by how far Utah has come in researching and understanding suicide. A team of legislative champions, state coordinators, medical examiners, and student mobile crisis team members now meet struggling Utahns early on to provide support and solutions.
Thanks to researchers like Gray, in the past three years alone, the University of Utah has secured funding of more than $125 million to conduct 131 research projects on mental illness and suicide prevention. “Eight years ago, I thought I would retire and nothing for suicide would have been done,” Gray says. "Now, when I do retire, I can retire in peace. Things will keep moving forward.”
Utah’s rising rates point to a larger issue—a troubling deficit in health care access. A third of Utah adults suffer from depression, and more than half of those lack access to treatment. Utah ranks last in the United States for mental health care resources.
To address this deficit, UNI helps hedge against access issues by offering resources on depression, mood disorders, and substance abuse. And just this year, the Huntsman Foundation committed $150 million to establishing a robust response to this crisis: the Huntsman Mental Health Institute.
“The first Huntsman generation made remarkable advancements in cancer research,” Gray says. “The second generation is focusing on the next important issue: mental health care and the stigma that comes with it.”
The moments preceding suicide are an opportunity to understand those populations vulnerable to suicide. Scott A. Langenecker, PhD (below) is one of several U of U researchers committed to studying the link between mental illness, suicide, and the brain.
And when we understand those vulnerable to suicide, we can better support them before it’s too late. Douglas D. Gray, MD, professor of psychiatry at the University of Utah, has been doing just that.
He first started studying the social and cultural factors behind Utah’s rising youth suicides in the late 1990s. At the time, Gray was one of only two people studying suicide in the state. “To help educate people, I used to fill my old Honda Civic with training pamphlets and hand them out on the weekends,” he says. “It was the loneliest job in town.”
Now, 20 years later, Gray is astounded by how far Utah has come in researching and understanding suicide. A team of legislative champions, state coordinators, medical examiners, and student mobile crisis team members now meet struggling Utahns early on to provide support and solutions.
Thanks to researchers like Gray, in the past three years alone, the University of Utah has secured funding of more than $125 million to conduct 131 research projects on mental illness and suicide prevention. “Eight years ago, I thought I would retire and nothing for suicide would have been done,” Gray says.
“Now, when I do retire, I can retire in peace. Things will keep moving forward.”
Utah’s rising rates point to a larger issue—a troubling deficit in health care access. A third of Utah adults suffer from depression, and more than half of those lack access to treatment. Utah ranks last in the United States for mental health care resources.
To address this deficit, UNI helps hedge against access issues by offering resources on depression, mood disorders, and substance abuse. And just this year, the Huntsman Foundation committed $150 million to establishing a robust response to this crisis: the Huntsman Mental Health Institute.
“The first Huntsman generation made remarkable advancements in cancer research,” Gray says. “The second generation is focusing on the next important issue: mental health care and the stigma that comes with it.”
RESEARCH INNOVATION
1 in 5
Utah adults
suffer from poor
mental health, but
Utah ranks
51st
in the nation
for access to
needed resources
In the last three years,
the University of Utah
has conducted:
131
suicide research projects
across 18 departments
with funding of more than
$125M
These
studies
explore suicide’s link to
genetics, veterans,
postpartum depression,
trauma, sleep,
social dynamics,
and more
In a recent mental health panel hosted by U of U Health at the 2020 Sundance Film Festival, Christena Huntsman Durham acknowledged that pervasive power of stigma:
Durham lost her own sister to addiction 10 years ago, teaching her the importance of having a place to find help without judgment. “If you’re at your kid’s soccer game and they sprain their ankle, you go to Urgent Care,” she said. “But if our child or loved one is suffering from mental illness, where do we go?”
We’re working to bridge this gap, but we can’t do it alone. The simplest solution starts with a conversation. Talk. Share. Listen.
In the face of this crisis, as with any other, there’s hope. For the first time in more than a decade, Utah’s suicide rate has stabilized. It’s a small feat, not yet significant, but it marks our place at a critical juncture. Here we ask, “What can we do next, together?”
In a recent mental health panel hosted by U of U Health at the 2020 Sundance Film Festival, Christena Huntsman Durham acknowledged that pervasive power of stigma:
Durham lost her own sister to addiction 10 years ago, teaching her the importance of having a place to find help without judgment. “If you’re at your kid’s soccer game and they sprain their ankle, you go to Urgent Care,” she said. “But if our child or loved one is suffering from mental illness, where do we go?”
We’re working to bridge this gap, but we can’t do it alone. The simplest solution starts with a conversation. Talk. Share. Listen.
In the face of this crisis, as with any other, there’s hope. For the first time in more than a decade, Utah’s suicide rate has stabilized. It’s a small feat, not yet significant, but it marks our place at a critical juncture. Here we ask, “What can we do next, together?”
EXPANDING CARE FOR ALL
The Huntsman Foundation
has pledged
$150M
to provide mental health
care for students and
underserved communities
The University
Neuropsychiatric Institute
(UNI) provides mental
health care for Utah
communities through
170
licensed inpatient staff
UNI offers
services
focusing on
children and adolescents,
maternal mental health,
substance use disorders,
and more
In FY2019,
UNI provided
51K+
unique encounters
of inpatient, outpatient, and
day treatment services
Thanks to counseling and family intervention following her suicide attempt, Julia Ludlow—now 17—is focused on the future. She finds it easier to open up about her thoughts, even the dark ones. “There’s less of a stigma around my feelings,” she says. “My depression is less mine and more shared.”
When Julia’s father talks about his daughter since her suicide attempt, pride and pain fight for prominence in his voice, even as it breaks with relief. “She’s very compassionate,” he says. “What I love about her is she’s taking her experience and using it in a way to help those around her.”
Julia now shares her story to help inspire greater change, recently alongside former Rep. Ben McAdams (D-Utah) in support of $2 million in funding for school-based suicide prevention programs. “As risk factors like depression and crisis become something we don’t hide in the shadows, [people] are looking for somebody to talk to,” McAdams said in a Salt Lake Tribune article. “We want to make sure those resources continue to be available... to people who need them.”
Julia is still the same young woman with a gentle smile, but she speaks now with a newfound confidence. She’s surer of herself, at peace. And she knows she’s not alone.
Thanks to counseling and family intervention following her suicide attempt, Julia Ludlow—now 17—is focused on the future. She finds it easier to open up about her thoughts, even the dark ones. “There’s less of a stigma around my feelings,” she says. “My depression is less mine and more shared.”
When Julia’s father talks about his daughter since her suicide attempt, pride and pain fight for prominence in his voice, even as it breaks with relief. “She’s very compassionate,” he says. “What I love about her is she’s taking her experience and using it in a way to help those around her.”
Julia now shares her story to help inspire greater change, recently alongside former Rep. Ben McAdams (D-Utah) in support of $2 million in funding for school-based suicide prevention programs. “As risk factors like depression and crisis become something we don’t hide in the shadows, [people] are looking for somebody to talk to,” McAdams said in a Salt Lake Tribune article. “We want to make sure those resources continue to be available... to people who need them.”
Julia is still the same young woman with a gentle smile, but she speaks now with a newfound confidence. She’s surer of herself, at peace. And she knows she’s not alone.
“State of Suffering”
Story and concept by Nafisa Masud
Design by:
Jesse Colby
Production support by:
Jessica Cagle and Mitch Sears
Extra thanks to
Stephen Dark